Categories / Shop Center

How to Get Your Products Handpicked

Creative Market March 31, 2021 · 7 min read
Our “handpicked” content is a constantly refreshed collection of what the Creative Market staff thinks is the absolute best of the recently uploaded products. In this article, we’ll take a look at just what it takes to get your products handpicked and hopefully get a nice boost in sales.

What is the Handpicked Section?

handpicked-new Across the site you’ll see some featured products in a section tilted “Handpicked.” True to its name, these items are carefully selected by our team, and the selection is refreshed several times per week. The benefit here for you as a shop owner is obvious: your item has the opportunity to occupy prime real estate at the top of a heavily-trafficked page. Ideally, every product you upload should have getting handpicked as a goal, just for the sake of the possible extra sales boost. The question then becomes, “How in the heck do I get my products in the Handpicked section?” Well you’re in luck, because I’m about to give you the inside scoop.

Step 1. Make Amazing Products

This goes without saying, but I’ll mention it anyway: if you want your products to get featured on the site, make sure they’re amazing. If you’re simply uploading old, ugly, unused designs that were never good enough for clients, don’t expect to be a hero in the Creative Market community. Instead, spend your time creating quality, extremely useful design resources that will make someone’s job easier. Our top authors often invest months of work into a single product. The items they upload have better features, more options, and are simply of a better quality than that of their competitors. When we see a shop owner putting this type of effort into their products, we love to feature them.

Step 2. Create Great Screenshots and Preview Images

Creative Market is a site made by designers for designers, so it makes perfect sense that shopping on Creative Market is a very visual experience. In short, the items with the best preview images get all the love: they get handpicked, they’re chosen for the weekly newsletters, and they get more purchases. It pains me to see shop owners put so much effort into creating an amazing product, and then totally drop the ball by being lazy with the screenshots. Screenshots are your primary form of marketing your product to users browsing the site, and it’s absolutely critical that you go all out and make them as great as possible.

At Least Three Screenshots, Preferably Five

handpicked-3 Here’s an extremely important tip to commit to memory: We almost never handpick a product with less than three screenshots. We’ll break this rule occasionally for a product that we know is amazing, but it’s definitely a good practice to launch all your products with all five screenshot slots filled.

The Cover Image is Everything

We encourage you to add several screenshots to your product, but among these, the cover image is king. This is the image that is shown across the site on the category, recent, and handpicked sections. One of the most surefire ways to get your product handpicked is to blow us away with your cover image.

Show Off Your Product Well

Your cover image should be as eye-catching and interesting as possible… but then what do you do with the rest of your screenshots? Use these as an opportunity to really show off the various benefits and features of your product. Show bonus elements, zoom in on the details, go crazy. Here are some examples of secondary screenshots that show off the product well.
  If you’re looking for some help creating awesome screenshots, Vintage Design Co. sells an awesome product called Product Preview Kit that makes it easy to show off your work in an interesting and attractive way.

Properly Sized and Cropped

One final note on screenshots: make sure they’re the right size. I know, that sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many shop owners upload images that get stretched or leave awkward empty space around them. Keep your screenshots at 1160px wide and at least 772px tall. screenshot

Step 3. Sweat the Small Stuff

Getting the visuals on your product right is only half the battle. When we’re looking for products to feature in the Handpicked section, we look way beyond the thumbnail and take everything about the product into consideration.

A Good Title and Description

Make sure your title is clear and communicates something about what the product is or does. Carefully fill out the description, being sure to address any questions people might have about what is included. The best descriptions are also excellent sales pitches. They get the reader excited about the product and what they can do with it. screenshot Dustin Lee of Retro Supply Co. gives some excellent advice in his piece on common mistakes people make in their product descriptions.


Really take the time to make sure all your metadata is filled out properly. Add as many tags as you can and fill out the relevant property information such as file types and supported software.

Fill Out Your Profile

Still haven’t uploaded a profile picture or header image? Then you’re probably not going to get your products into the Handpicked section. We like to feature products from shops that are committed enough to make their little storefronts personal and interesting.

Step 4. Be Unique

I know that’s a painful cliche that makes designers wince, but it really does count. When we see shop owners doing something new that we haven’t seen before, we’re much more likely to handpick that item than when we see them mimicking the tactics of others again and again. What works for others probably won’t work as well for you. Find your own niche or style and run with it.
  A great example of this tactic is Jessica Johnson, who recently found great success with her “Glam” line of products, which is comprised of some really interesting effects that we hadn’t seen from other shops. We could tell that Jessica went all out and really poured her heart into her work, and we rewarded that by featuring her in our emails and handpicking her products.

A Note On Photos

The advice above applies to most of the products across the site. One interesting area where you may have trouble applying some of this advice is photography. For instance, you can’t add five screenshots, you just have the one photo! My best advice here is to follow steps three and four above, and more importantly, take incredible, natural photos. We don’t like to feature photos that look overly processed or painfully staged. Natural, genuine photography that doesn’t feel like the crappy stock you see on every other site is our primary goal with photos.

The More You Know…

There you have it, you now have the inside scoop into how to get your products featured prominently on Creative Market. The key takeaway is that shop owners who constantly get their items handpicked tend to be those that work hard to make sure all their products not only contain amazing work, but are presented in an enticing and professional way.
Header image created using HANDS – Hand Drawn by BusOne.
Lettering Worksheets
Getting started with hand lettering?
Free lettering worksheets

Download these worksheets and start practicing with simple instructions and tracing exercises.

Download now!
About the Author
Creative Market

Making beautiful design simple & accessible to all.

View More Posts
Go to My Shop
Related Articles
  • What about the old saying "less is more" - does that not apply here? 8 years ago
  • Great article, and thanks for the shoutout! :) 8 years ago
  • Great article, thanks for the tips Josh! 8 years ago
  • A couple of my products got handpicked and those are the products that have a lot of hours in them for that reason, and that is awesome. Other products with an equal amount of work and thought sadly don't make it. That does not mean there not as awesome. Check out for example and tell me what you think. Serious, tell me what you think. 8 years ago
  • One extremely important element that I failed to mention here is simply competition. There are only nine handpicked slots for each category. Some days we find 15, or heck, 30 products that are good enough to feature and we have to make tough decisions. Never ever assume that not getting handpicked means that a product wasn't excellent. It's often the case that there are simply too many excellent products for us to choose from! 8 years ago
  • @Derek Stevenson It depends on the topic. We've found that if we're trying convince someone to fork over their hard earned money on a creative asset, five screenshots work better than only one. In that case, more is more! Obviously, there's a point of diminishing returns there, which is why we only have five slots. Also, in the case of something like tags, more is definitely better so that searchers have an easier time finding your product. 8 years ago
  • @Josh Johnson Thanks for the input. I use all 5 photo slots but I find it hard to show how a simple flyer template can be "awesome" in my main cover photo. I've had quite a few products reach hand-picked status and the email as well but I find myself not really being able to show "cool" and "amazing" features with many of my products because the majority of them are B2B style templates. I always shoot for a minimalist approach when creating preview images because I don't want to make it seem like the prospect / potential buyer is going to be getting more than what is actually being offered. I try to make it clear as possible that they are getting what they see, without using any type of misleading text that may lead to a can of worms being opened up. For example, one of the product listed above says "Millions of options made effortless" which to me seems misleading. How can we as authors justify those types of statements in our product images without getting ourselves in trouble? 8 years ago
  • @Derek Stevenson I like how you show off your flyers. Without reading anything, I can see that you include different colors. You definitely hit over the three screenshot suggestion on every product I see. Looks great! 8 years ago
  • @Josh Johnson thanks but I still feel like the other preview images throughout the site trump mine. I find it very difficult to show the benefit of purchasing a template in my main preview image. IDK, it's tough but I notice these other preview images are more for tools and what-not. 8 years ago
  • Whoahhhhh! @Josh Johnson, thanks so much!! I've recently been transitioning from client work to doing my various shops full time, so this is really awesome and rewarding! It definitely helps to be handpicked, and I strive to make every use of my opportunity. You have to make sure your product is good, answer every email quickly and keep your customers happy and smiling! I may be missing sleep and working even harder than before, but it definitely feels more rewarding. 8 years ago
  • Great tips @Josh Johnson! Will keep this in mind for future items. :) 8 years ago
  • Thanks for the tips! 8 years ago
  • Great article, thanks @Josh Johnson! 8 years ago
  • Thank you so much @Josh Johnson! 8 years ago
  • Thanks for the great tips! Btw many thanks for my flyer that was handpicked today!! 8 years ago
  • We were so honoured to be selected as one of the handpicked for Wordpress Themes when we launched our first product three weeks ago. Great article and thanks again! 8 years ago
  • Wow, this article is filled with a ton of great info! I'm definitely going to keep all of this in mind when I'm publishing new products. I know that spending extra time and care on my previews helped but I have a lot I can still work on Great tips, @Josh Johnson Awesome article, as always! 8 years ago
  • It was a huge rush when i got my flyer template featured, and i realise now that i didn't have enough screenshots, so less can be more in some cases. The great thing about Creative Market is that they are flexible and treat every item individually, not according to a bunch of 'rules'. 8 years ago
  • Thank you! 8 years ago
  • Very nice to learn this stuff! I'm curious if the handpicked section showcases old products or repeats ever? (Not bad in either case). 8 years ago
  • Thank you! very nice infirmation! 8 years ago
  • Please bring it back. 7 years ago
  • Thanks! 6 years ago
  • Thank you so much @Josh Johnson :) 6 years ago
  • Thanks for the post ! @Josh Johnson 6 years ago
  • I'm new here, hopefully I will get my products hand picked some day. 6 years ago
  • Thanks for sharing :) 6 years ago
  • Anonymous
    Thanks for sharing :) 6 years ago
  • Thank you! 6 years ago
  • Thanks for the detailed step-by-step instruction, Josh Johnson ! 6 years ago
  • Great and helpful article! Thank you! 6 years ago
  • thanks for the advice, but i'm afraid it won't work everytime 5 years ago
  • Thanks, a great information!!! 5 years ago
  • Thank you for the great tips! 5 years ago
  • This really helps! Thank you @Josh Johnson 5 years ago
  • I just recently opened my new and sparkly shop and I find this article useful, I'm exited to put every advice to good use. Hopefully some of my colorful products will make the front page soon. :) 5 years ago
  • Great info. The Handpicked items are lovely, but I've noticed (for Illustrations) they are almost exclusively flowers/plants and cute animals clipart. So while I've been pleasantly surprised by the number of sales I've made, my illustrations/clipart mostly features women and fashion, so it's not likely to be selected. 5 years ago
  • Great Article, thank you @Josh Johnson !! 5 years ago
  • Thanks for the useful tips! 5 years ago
  • Hi :) Thanks for the tip. I think I will soon succeed! 5 years ago
  • Thanks @Josh Johnson for sharing. Hope it will be helpful for all new shop owners. 4 years ago
  • Awesome tips here. Really helps to get your products noticed. Never been hand picked but hopefully we will soon. Check out our store we make some awesome psd mockup packs 4 years ago
  • Excellent post....Thanks 4 years ago
  • Thanks 4 years ago
  • Thank you so much for picking my kitty in the Garden Collection for the handpicked today ! This is super exciting as we just opened our shop ! So we have been drawing up all this art so more sets to come ! We are so excited about this new venture ! 4 years ago
  • Thanks for sharing this great article @Josh Johnson It has been very useful for me and I just started to apply this info to my new item and also I will update the previous ones. Keep working to get my products handpicked! 4 years ago
  • Is it important in what day I uploaded my project?and what day is better?Monday? Thursday? I was hand-picked once few years ago and never again( 2 years ago